Brother's Pizzeria NY Menu

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to Brother's Pizzeria NY, an iconic eatery nestled in Staten Island, where tradition meets flavor in every slice. With a casual vibe and a menu designed to satisfy everyone, this pizzeria caters to both pizza enthusiasts and health-conscious diners alike.

  • Specialty Pizzas: The standout here is the Brother's Supreme, a hearty blend of pepperoni, sausage, and fresh veggies, all crowned on a perfectly baked crust.
  • Hot Subs: Don't miss the meatball and sausage Parmigiana, delivering a comforting taste reminiscent of classic Italian-American fare.
  • Vegetarian Options: Options abound, including the Veggie Supreme, making it a go-to for families and groups.

Customer reviews consistently highlight the friendly service and welcoming atmosphere, reinforcing its reputation as a local favorite. Whether you're dining in with the family or grabbing a quick takeout, Brother's Pizzeria NY guarantees a satisfying experience that keeps patrons returning for more.

Salads Steak Fries Cheeseburgers Breadsticks Brothers Pizza White Pizza Specialty Pizzas Toppings Whole Cold Subs & Wedges Whole Hot Subs Side Orders

Salads

Antipasto Salad
$6.75

Chef Salad
$6.75

Steak Salad
$7.25

Chicken Salad
$7.25

Buffalo Chicken Salad
$7.40

Cajun Chicken Salad
$7.40

Tuna Salad
$7.40

Tossed Salad
$3.25

Regular
$3.25

Bacon & Cheddar
$2.75

Beerf Battered Onion Rings
$2.50

Steak Fries

Cheeseburgers

1/4 Cheeseburger

(am.cheese, l, t, m, onion)
$2.75

Cheddy Burger

(cheddar cheese & fried onions) add bacon or mushrooms $0.75
$2.75

Breadsticks
$3.75

Breadsticks

Brothers Pizza

16 Inch W/ Mozzarella
$1.85

14 Inch W/ Mozzarella
$1.65

10 Inch W/ Mozzarella
$0.75

Sicilian
$1.85

Slices
$1.50

Side Of Garlic Butter Or Extra Sauce
$0.75

16 Inch
$10.85

14 Inch
$1.65

10 Inch
$0.75

White Pizza

Specialty Pizzas

Brother's Supreme

pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green pepper, onion
$15.25

Meat Supreme

ham, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ground beef
$15.25

Veggie Supreme

onion, mushroom, tomato, green peppers, black olive
$15.25

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

chopped grilled chicken with mild wing sauce
$15.25

Philly Cheesesteak

onion, green peppers, mozzarella and steak
$15.25

Side Of Garlic Butter Of Extra Saue
$0.75

Toppings

Toppings

Whole Cold Subs & Wedges

Super Italian
$6.20

Roast Beef
$6.20

Turkey
$5.95

Turkey & Bacon With Provolone
$6.20

Italian
$5.70

Ham
$4.70

Salami
$4.70

Tuna
$5.70

Provolone
$5.70

Veggie
$5.95

Meatball Parmigiana
$5.95

Sausage Parmigiana
$5.95

Veal Parmigiana
$6.20

Eggplant Parmigiana
$6.20

Pizza Sub W/ Pepperoni
$5.95

Breaded Chicken Fillet

(l, t, m hp & onion)
$6.50

Breaded Buffalo Chicken Filler

(l, t, m, hp, o & mild sauce)
$6.65

Breaded Chicken Parmigiana
$6.50

Grilled Chicken Fillet

(l, t, m, hp & onion)
$5.50

Grilled Chicken Parmigiana
$5.50

Cheesesteak

(l, t, m, hp & onion)
$6.50

Cheeseburger Sub
$6.50

Fish Fillet Sub
$6.50

Canadian Bacon W/ Provolone
$6.50

Whole Hot Subs

Side Orders

Buffalo Wings

(choice of blue cheese or ranch)
$5.25

Mozzarella Stix
$4.50

Meatballs With Mozzarella
$3.95

Garlic Bread With Sauce
$2.00

Chicken Fingers W/ Steak Fries (3 Fingers)
$4.75

Cannoli (italian Pastry)
$2.20

Jalapeno Poppers
$4.50